Guaranteed Irish

Compare Top BBQ Grills: Electric vs Gas vs Charcoal + Recipes

Compare Top BBQ Grills: Electric vs Gas vs Charcoal + Recipes

Zora Wang |

Ah, BBQ season. The smell of burgers in the air, the sun shining just right — it's grilling time. Whether you're a weekend warrior or just here for the ribs, picking the right BBQ matters. We’ve done the meat-flipping for you with this ultimate BBQ guide, packed with sizzling picks from Heavins.ie.

Types of BBQ Grills: Which One is Right for You?

Feature Gas BBQ Charcoal BBQ Electric BBQ
Heat-up Time Fast Moderate Fast
Flavor Moderate Smokiness Rich Smoky Flavor Depends on model (Ninja = woodfire smoky!)
Clean-up Moderate Messy Easy
Fuel Type Propane/Gas Charcoal Electricity/Wood Pellets (Ninja)
Cost Range Medium to High Low to Medium Medium

Other Factors to Consider When Buying a BBQ Grill

Choosing the type of BBQ (gas, charcoal, electric) is only the beginning. The perfect grill depends just as much on your lifestyle, available space, and how many people you’re feeding. Here’s how to zero in on what matters most to you:

For 2 People or Couples 

You don’t need a behemoth 4-burner grill if you’re cooking for just two. Smaller grills heat up faster, take up less space, and are easier to clean—perfect for balconies or compact patios.

What to look for:

  • 1–2 burners or compact design
  • Quick heat-up time
  • Easy storage

Top Picks:

Feature Outback Omega 200 Charcoal Kettle BBQ 17" Ninja Woodfire OG701UK
Fuel Type Gas Charcoal Electric + Wood Pellets
Cooking Area  50 x 36 cm 41cm Diameter 35 x 45 cm
Smoking Function ✅Indirect heat only ✅ Built-in smoker with wood pellets
Heat-Up Time Fast (approx. 10 mins) Slow (15–20 mins) Very fast (preheats in minutes)
Temperature Control Dial-controlled burners Manual (vents & charcoal) Digital precision control
Assembly Required ✅ (moderate assembly) ✅Minimal assembly ❌ (plug & cook)


For Families & Entertaining

When you're cooking for a crowd (or a hungry family), size and features matter. You’ll want plenty of cooking surface, consistent heat, and maybe even some bells and whistles like side burners or smokers.

What to look for:

  • 3+ burners or a large grilling surface
  • Side tables or warming racks
  • Versatility (e.g., smoking, air frying, etc.)

Top Picks:

Feature Outback Jupiter 4 Burner Gas BBQ Sahara Performer 3 Burner Gas BBQ Ninja Woodfire Pro XL
Fuel Type Gas Gas Electric + Wood Pellets
Cooking Area  64 x 42 cm  49 x 52 cm 35 x 45 cm
Smoking Function Optional with smoker box Built-in smoker with wood pellets
Pizza Oven Function
Heat-Up Time Fast (approx. 10 mins) Very fast  Preheats in minutes
Temperature Control 4 independent burners with knobs Precise gas controls Digital control with smart sensors
Assembly Required ✅ (moderate to large setup) ✅  ❌ (plug & cook)

Portable BBQs: For Camping, Picnics & Small Patios

If you love to BBQ on the go or have limited space, portability is key. Look for grills that are lightweight, easy to assemble, and can be safely transported.

What to look for:

  • Easy setup and cleanup
  • Lightweight and compact
  • Sturdy for travel or uneven ground

Top Picks:

Feature Ninja Woodfire Electric BBQ Grill & Smoker | OG701UK George Foreman Indoor/Outdoor Grill Charcoal Kettle BBQ 17"  Outback Omega 200
Fuel Type Electric + Wood Pellets Electric Charcoal Gas
Cooking Area  28 x 37 cm  44.5 cm diameter  43 cm diameter  50 x 36 cm 
Smoking Function Built-in smoker with wood pellets Indirect heat only
Air Fryer Function Yes – built-in air fryer mode
Heat-Up Time Very fast (preheats in minutes) Fast (approx. 8–10 mins) Slow (15–20 mins) Fast (approx. 10 mins)
Temperature Control Digital precision control Adjustable dial Manual (vents & charcoal) Dial-controlled burners
Assembly Required ❌ (plug & cook) ✅Minimal  ✅Minimal assembly ✅ (moderate assembly)

What Are the Must-Have BBQ Accessories

No great BBQ experience is complete without the right accessories. Whether you're firing up a gas grill, getting smoky with charcoal, or going high-tech with the Ninja Woodfire, a few must-haves will make the process easier, cleaner, and way more enjoyable. Here's a quick rundown of the essentials every grill-master should have on hand:

To top it all off, we even caught up with Today Show’s chef, Kevin Dundon, to chat about the best way to make the most of the Ninja Woodfire Electric BBQ Grill. His advice? Keep it simple, let the woodfire flavor shine, and don’t be afraid to experiment with smoke.

Whether you're grilling steaks or air-frying wings, the Ninja makes it easy to impress. And to get you started, we’ve attached some delicious, easy-to-follow recipes that’ll have you grilling like a pro in no time. Happy BBQ-ing!

Ninja Woodifre BBQ Grill & Smoker with Kevin Dundon Michelin Star Chef

Unlock Michelin-Inspired BBQ: Kevin Dundon's Guide to the Ninja Woodfire

Frequently Asked Questions

How to clean BBQ grills?

  • How to clean BBQ grill grates: Use a grill brush and warm, soapy water. For tough spots, baking soda and vinegar work wonders.
  • Electric BBQs: Always unplug first. Wipe down interior with a damp cloth. Remove and wash grill plates if detachable.
  • Charcoal BBQs: Remove ash after every use. Scrub grates and bowl with warm water.
  • Smokers like the Ninja: Clean drip trays and smoke box regularly.

How do you grill asparagus on a BBQ?

It’s super easy—and tasty! Just toss your asparagus in a little olive oil, season with salt and pepper, and place it across the grill grates (perpendicular so it doesn’t fall through). Grill for 3–5 minutes, turning once, until charred and tender.

👉 Bonus: We’ve got a full recipe featuring grilled asparagus and a juicy New York strip steak—check it out here: Grilled Strip Steak with Asparagus Recipe

Are electric barbecues worth it?

Absolutely—especially models like the Ninja Woodfire, which offer grilling, smoking, and even air frying in one compact unit.

Does an electric BBQ need charcoal?

Nope! Electric BBQs don’t require charcoal. However, the Ninja Woodfire uses wood pellets to add authentic smoky flavor.

Can you leave an electric barbecue outside?

Only if it’s weather-resistant and covered. Otherwise, it’s best to store it indoors when not in use. We advise purchasing a BQ cover which you can find in our BBQ Accessories

Can you use an electric grill in the rain?

Not recommended. For safety, always keep electric BBQs away from water or use them in covered outdoor spaces.

Do electric grills use a lot of electricity?

Not really. They're typically energy-efficient and heat up quickly, making them a great option for everyday use.

Which is better: an air fryer or an electric grill?

For grilling? The electric grill wins. But some models, like the Ninja Woodfire, combine both—best of both worlds!